In Harriet’S Tragic Death, The Vulnerability Caused Past Times Huntington’S Illness – Only Likewise The Even Out Of A Beautiful Soul

On the morn of Apr 8, spell out for her cherished daily walk, 71-year-old Huntington’s illness patient Harriet Hartl died tragically later on existence struck yesteryear an Amtrak prepare at a pedestrian crossing close her story inwards Del Mar, CA, inwards San Diego County.

The story of Harriet’s decease encapsulates the fearfulness of all Huntington’s families – indeed, the identify unit of measurement of any individual suffering from diseases that hamper perceptions too mobility. HD, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, too other such disorders brand people extremely vulnerable to the world.

Harriet’s passing farther highlights the demand to break effective treatments for these conditions, which scientists conduct maintain establish peculiarly hard to fathom.

However, the daze of Harriet’s decease should non overshadow the beautiful, dearest soul she represented for her family, friends, too swain members of the San Diego-area hard disk community, including the monthly back upwards grouping she loved to attend.

That’s where I met her: she ever had a grinning too form words for others. She participated inwards the breakout grouping for the affected, split upwards from the untested at-risk too presymptomatic factor carriers similar me.

We got to know each other amend through this blog, which Harriet read regularly. She sometimes responded amongst encouraging e-mails regarding my family’s struggles amongst HD. She also shared some of her journeying amongst the disease.

Brett Hartl asset photograph of woman raise Harriet (photo yesteryear Gene Veritas, aka Kenneth P. Serbin) (To enlarge a photo, simply click on the image.)

‘Bad things tin happen’ to hard disk people

On May 17, I spoke amongst Harriet’s exclusively kid too caregiver Brett Hartl at their Del Mar residence, simply a few yards from the prepare rails too the Pacific Ocean.

“It was a tough blow when she died, because it was sudden, too sort of an accident, inwards the sense that it wasn’t the down-the-road thing that would conduct maintain come upwards eventually,” said Brett, 39, an attorney for the Center for Biological Diversity. “It’s been relatively slow for me to wind my caput around it too procedure it, because frankly I know plenty almost hard disk to empathise that bad things tin happen. It’s hard for people amongst hard disk to bargain amongst complex tasks that nosotros conduct maintain for granted.

“At her age, when she would conduct maintain her walk, that would conduct maintain all of her focus. I tin simply totally envision her focusing on walking too tuning out the residual of the world.”

The morn of Apr 8, a Sunday, Brett went out for a run. Noting that Harriet had been out longer than usual, he checked her GPS place on his smartphone too saw that she was nearby. He expected to come across upwards amongst her equally she returned home.

However, equally Brett neared the railroad pedestrian crossing, he noticed a prepare stopped on the tracks too many law cars.

“I started to acquire a footling combat of that feeling,” Brett recalled sadly.

He returned to the apartment, hoping to break his mother. Instead, checking her GPS place again, he saw that she was located correct on the track.

Fearing the worst, Brett drove to the scene. He saw her body, which the law had covered. Because the officers had Harriet’s smartphone, driver’s license, too Huntington’s illness identification card, they chop-chop confirmed her identification amongst Brett.

Brett observes the scene of the accident. The official pedestrian crossing is located at the sidewalk on the far side side of the street (photo yesteryear Gene Veritas).

Crossing the tracks

How, some wondered, could a individual non notice an oncoming train?

“People don’t realize all the footling things that simply don’t quite function correct inwards someone’s hear amongst Huntington’s,” he explained. “When she was focusing on exercise too walking, that was it. That was in all probability all she could concealment at i time.”

Brett, who is silent awaiting an official accident study from Amtrak, said the prepare was traveling at almost 50 miles per hour, a measure speed for that stretch. He believes she was killed instantly.

“It was non a glancing blow,” he observed. “I doubtfulness she fifty-fifty noticed.”

To complicate matters, the crossing is located simply around a curvature inwards the track, at a busy traffic intersection, too simply a few yards from the ocean. The surf, vehicle traffic, too other dissonance in all probability obscured the train’s advance, Brett said. In that expanse the prepare rarely uses its klaxon (horn), he added.

“Here inwards Southern California, everybody crosses the railroad tracks illegally,” Brett continued, recalling that some other private was killed on the tracks recently. In other words, they don’t use the legal pedestrian crossings.

As nosotros observed the crossing, nosotros noted the posted suicide prevention sign. We saw a number of people become through the crossing without looking downwards the tracks.

“She had a route,” Brett remembered. “Sometimes she would say, ‘I took the shortcut. I crossed the tracks.’ I said, ‘Don’t make that. Only cross at the crossing station [the legal pedestrian crossing] downwards there. It’s besides dangerous. What if you lot autumn too can’t acquire up?’”

‘A terrible confluence of events’

The weakened sense of one’s environs caused yesteryear hard disk certainly exacerbated the situation, he said.

“You’d conduct maintain to almost plough around over your shoulder to expression – which, again, normal people tin do,” Brett said. “She was walking inwards the same direction equally the train, too then it came upwards behind her, too the prepare was inwards reverse. So the engine was inwards the back, too then it’s extra serenity until it’s genuinely passed. It was simply a terrible confluence of events.”

Brett is non angry at Amtrak. He asked administrators in that place to tell the employees on the prepare that they were non responsible for Harriet’s death.

“HD is inwards my hear was responsible for her death, because she couldn’t conduct maintain the normal things that nosotros conduct maintain for granted,” he said. “In this case, it was crossing the prepare tracks.”

A passion for travel

Harriet Potash was born inwards New York City inwards 1947 too grew upwards inwards the area. She studied sociology at Monmouth University inwards New Jersey. Around that time, she met hereafter husband, Larry Hartl.

Harriet worked equally a move agent, inwards advertising, too equally a teacher. Larry became a producer for the ABC-TV newsmagazine 20/20. He also worked at NBC-TV.

His chore took him too Harriet to dozens of countries, including the old Soviet Union, a unopen Communist regime.

“Travel was i of her large passions,” Brett remembered. “She’d been to over 50 countries. Even later on her diagnosis, inwards 2011 [at historic menstruum 64], she didn’t permit that halt her from traveling. We did a trip together to Nippon inwards 2013. Then nosotros did the trip to consider the polar bears simply this terminal Nov upwards inwards Canada, which was hard for someone for HD.”

Before hard disk struck, Harriet too Brett also did challenging hikes such equally a 15-mile trek inwards Montana’s Glacier Park.

Brett reflected: “I mean value people sometimes forget that people amongst hard disk used to hold upwards completely capable too salubrious too active.”

Above, Harriet inwards Moscow, 1973. Below, inwards Republic of Ecuador inwards the mid-2000s (family photos).

Confronting HD

Not long later on Larry died, Harriet inwards 2003 moved to the San Diego expanse to escape the harsh East Coast winters. 

In 2010, she started falling a lot. Brett recommended that she consider a neurologist. That led to testing for HD, a illness unknown to the family.

Now, however, it became clear that Harriet’s begetter had also had hard disk too passed it downwards to her: he had emotional outbursts too chorea (involuntary movements), ii typical symptoms of HD. His apparent onslaught – without testing – came real late. He died at 90.

Both Harriet too Brett took a proactive approach to HD.

“I got tested also, inwards 2011,” Brett said, disclosing that the resultant was negative. “Most of the immediate identify unit of measurement did. My approach, simply existence who I am, was that I wanted to larn everything I could almost it too empathise it, the consequences.”

Most people inwards Brett’s province of affairs postpone or avoid testing.

“For me it was: ‘Well, amend to larn at nowadays than finding out xxx years from now,’” he said. “It’s non fun. But inwards the long run it was a expert choice.”

So far, none of Harriet’s father’s siblings or her cousins conduct maintain tested positive, Brett said. He knows of exclusively i other relative amongst HD.

Harriet’s approach

Harriet regularly attended the San Diego back upwards group of the Huntington’s Disease Society of America (HDSA).

“Having a rigid community of other folks going through that was real helpful to her,” Brett said. “She genuinely enjoyed those other people a lot.”

Harriet also participated inwards interrogation studies too clinical trials aimed at agreement hard disk too finding treatments.

She also hoped to participate inwards the Phase 3 trial of IONIS-HTT_Rx, developed yesteryear Ionis’s historic Phase 1/2a trial.

Swiss pharmaceutical giant trial sites inwards the USA volition hold upwards included. (The Phase 1/2a trial was non opened upwards to USA residents.)

“She had something to expression frontward to,” Brett said. “She was real excited almost the Phase 3 for that side yesteryear side drug. She wanted to brand certain that she got inwards the study.”

Harriet had also simply started taking here to read more). Xenazine too Austedo are the exclusively drugs approved for hard disk inwards the U.S.

“I mean value it made a difference,” Brett said of Austedo. “It calmed downwards some of the movements. She liked it. It helped her slumber amend at night. She wasn’t equally restless.”

In improver to daily walks, Harriet also worked amongst a physical therapist too practiced yoga, Brett noted.

“She genuinely got a lot out of daily exercise,” he said. “That was i of her greatest joys too things to conception her 24-hour interval around.”

Just weeks earlier Harriet’s death, she had decided to donate her encephalon for hard disk research. Sadly, the impairment from the accident made that impossible, Brett said.

‘A real friendly lady’

Although hard disk impedes speech, Harriet could silent communicate. She kept mentally active too reached out to the community. After her diagnosis, she continued to instruct herself Spanish, a science that allowed her to make volunteer tutoring at a schoolhouse for underprivileged children. She also volunteered at the San Diego Botanic Garden.

Family, friends, too acquaintances remembered Harriet equally outgoing too kind. During a trip to Costa Rica, she started talking amongst children on a beach. “She simply struck upwards a conversation inwards Castilian amongst them,” Brett recalled.

“She was very, real outgoing too opened upwards amongst people,” Brett commented. “She cared a lot almost their ain personal issues. Even simply the other day, at the pizza identify downwards the street, I told some of the folks what happened. They ever recognized her equally ‘the real friendly lady.’ It didn’t genuinely thing if she knew you lot for a minute, or a year.” 

Remembering Harriet’s whole life

There was no religious service for Harriet. According to her wishes, her trunk was cremated.

However, iii weeks later on her death, Brett too Harriet’s San Diego-area friends held a modest remembrance of her at the beach.

Later this summer, Brett too friends too identify unit of measurement volition scatter her ashes inwards the Atlantic Ocean close Jones Beach, Long Island, where hubby Larry’s ashes were spread.

“She loved both oceans,” Brett said.

He also encourages people to persuasion the online memorial photograph album he posted: https://photos.app.goo.gl/2sjV7LlttaohhVkq1.

“It’s a amend story than I could genuinely tell,” he said of the album. “She certain did a lot. She shouldn’t hold upwards remembered simply inwards her hard disk state.”

Brett also ready a donation page inwards Harriet's accolade to back upwards HDSA-San Diego.

Share this post