Woody Guthrie, Huntington’S Disease, In Addition To Our Duty To Ameliorate Caregiving

By revisiting the huge, long-abandoned New Bailiwick of Jersey mental infirmary where radical songwriter in addition to performer Woody Guthrie struggled for 5 years amongst the symptoms of Huntington’s disease, lensman in addition to author Phillip Buehler provides us amongst a valuable novel perspective on the crisis inwards attention for people disabled yesteryear neurological disorders.

In Woody Guthrie’s Wardy Forty: Greystone Park State Hospital Revisited (Woody Guthrie Publications, Inc., 2013, 162 pages), Buehler, a specialist on derelict buildings, captures the rooms, corridors, in addition to grounds of the psychiatric facility that housed Guthrie betwixt 1956 in addition to 1961. It had over 6,000 patients in addition to had some 2,000 employees at its top inwards the 1960s.

A companion volume, Woody Guthrie’s Wardy Forty: The Interviews, provides background from those who knew Guthrie or are involved inwards the crusade against Huntington’s. (Click here to buy the books.)

Woody Guthrie (above) in addition to the novel books almost his fourth dimension at Greystone Park State Hospital (below) (photos from www.woodyguthrie.org)

Utterly debilitated in addition to unable to speak, Woodrow Wilson Guthrie, the composer of “This Land is Your Land,” died of Huntington’s at Creedmoor State Hospital inwards Queens, NY, inwards Oct 1967 at the historic menses of 55.

Today the U.S. has an estimated 5.4 1000000 Alzheimer’s illness patients, in addition to an additional 14.9 1000000 theater unit of measurement members in addition to friends grapple amongst the illness every bit caregivers or inwards other ways. About 1 1000000 people endure from Parkinson’s disease.

Huntington’s illness (HD) patients issue 30,000, amongst an additional 150,000-250,000 at risk. The authorities classified hard disk every bit an “orphan,” or rare, illness because of the relatively small-scale issue of people affected (fewer than 200,000). Numerous other disorders have got similar symptoms. By mid-century, every bit many every bit 120 1000000 people worldwide volition endure from dementia.

The basis must shoulder a massive caregiving burden. Most people affected yesteryear such illnesses volition require attention ranging from in-home assistance to admission to a nursing home.

While researchers have got made strides studying the symptoms, causes, in addition to handling of these conditions, caregiving has non advanced. Professional caregivers typically earn really depression reward in addition to have niggling training. Even many doctors cannot properly diagnose rare disorders such every bit HD.

“Long term attention remains a scandal inwards the United States,” Alice Wexler, Ph.D., a board fellow member of the HD-related Hereditary Disease Foundation in addition to author of 2 books on the disease, writes inwards a brief history of the illness included inwards Buehler’s book. “Persons living amongst hard disk in addition to their loved ones – in addition to all those amongst chronic neurodegenerative in addition to psychiatric illnesses – silent struggle mightily to notice appropriate in addition to affordable back upward in addition to care, at dwelling theater spell they are silent able, inwards facilities when they are not.”

In a representative that shocked the hard disk community, inwards May 2013 a 49-year-old, late-stage hard disk patient was allegedly strangled inwards an Oregon nursing dwelling theater yesteryear some other patient whom police describe described every bit suffering from “severe dementia.”

To complicate matters further, the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act does non supply protection to people seeking life, disability, in addition to long-term attention insurance. Thus, every bit genetic testing, including total deoxyribonucleic acid sequencing, promises to go ubiquitous, people run the endangerment of non getting the coverage they volition most demand every bit they alive ever longer lives. Only iii states (California, Oregon, in addition to Vermont) prohibit this type of discrimination.

Lives instantly transformed

My ain theater unit of measurement has struggled amongst Huntington’s illness since the belatedly 1980s, when my woman raise Carol Serbin started having foreign swings inwards mood. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 few years later, she developed chorea, the involuntary movements most Huntington’s sufferers develop, causing some to appear every bit if they are dancing.

Nobody inwards the theater unit of measurement understood what was incorrect until inwards 1995 a neurologist suspected Huntington’s. Just 2 years before, researchers had concluded a two-decade quest to notice the disease-causing gene, which they called “huntingtin,” similar the illness named for the American physician George Huntington.

In 1872, Dr. Huntington published an article describing HD’s symptoms in addition to definitively establishing it every bit a genetically transmitted condition. Everybody has this gene, which is essential for life, but when it expands beyond its normal size, it causes encephalon cells to die. The regain of the cistron allowed for a definitive examine for the disease, though, unfortunately, scientific discipline has yet to supply effective treatments, much less a cure.

Receiving the intelligence of my mother’s diagnosis the twenty-four hr menses after Christmas 1995, my married adult woman Regina in addition to I saw our lives transformed before us inwards an instant. With no handling or cure, hard disk was fatal. All children of an affected raise had a 50-50 of inheriting the condition. Most people experience illness attack betwixt the ages of thirty in addition to 50, in addition to everybody amongst a sure as shooting score of cistron expansion or greater volition develop the condition.

My mother’s diagnosis in addition to the fright that I mightiness comport the genetic expansion compelled me to contend dorsum inwards whatever agency I could. Regina in addition to I instantly started attending the local back upward grouping of the Huntington’s Disease Society of America (HDSA), in addition to I became an HDSA advocate.

I began writing almost my experiences inwards this blog. Because of fright of genetic discrimination, until recently, I performed all of this behind the scenes, for representative writing nether a pseudonym, Gene Veritas.

The fright that I carried the mutation led Regina in addition to me to postpone starting a family. By 1999, however, nosotros agreed to try. First, I decided to acquire tested. I was particularly worried almost transmitting the mutation, because sometimes men top on an fifty-fifty longer expansion, resulting inwards an early-onset shape known every bit juvenile Huntington’s.

Our worst fears were confirmed: I had the same expansion every bit my woman raise in addition to would probable develop the illness inwards my forties or fifties.

We in addition to therefore embarked on the most hard determination of our lives: the testing of our missy inwards the womb (so-called preimplantation genetic diagnosis was non yet available). After weeks of waiting for the results, nosotros received the happiest intelligence of our lives: our “miracle baby” was HD-free! Today Bianca is a thriving middle schoolhouse student.

The genetic mirror

Throughout this period, I juggled my roles every bit college professor, manful somebody raise in addition to husband, in addition to Huntington’s illness advocate – all spell watching my mother’s inexorable decline. In add-on to her psychiatric symptoms in addition to chorea, she suffered from the tertiary manifestation of the hard disk triad: cognitive loss in addition to dementia.

“Each run across amongst my mom became a persuasion into a nightmarish genetic mirror,” I wrote to a physician friend who included my story anonymously inwards a September 2005 Washington Post article on HD. “I watched her torso jerk, caput bob, in addition to fingers fret. One black I found her wandering precisely about our theater confused in addition to one-half naked. Within a yr she lost most of her capacity to speak. She ate clumsily amongst her hands.”

Around that time, because my “HD warrior” in addition to caregiver manful somebody raise Paul could no longer attention for my woman raise at home, he placed her inwards a nursing home. She died quietly inwards her slumber inwards Feb 2006, at 68.

Paul in addition to Carol Serbin (photo yesteryear Gene Veritas)

Finally seeing the beauty

Following Guthrie through the pages of Buehler’s books, I was prompted to reverberate on my human relationship amongst my woman raise every bit she struggled amongst hard disk every bit good every bit on how our arrangement of caregiving must improve.

Disease communities are used to emphasizing the destruction of the their detail conditions. The destruction is real. But in that location is to a greater extent than to the somebody than the illness. I regret non having the emotional forcefulness in addition to presence of hear to have got seen my woman raise to a greater extent than every bit a somebody in addition to less every bit a hear in addition to torso racked yesteryear the symptoms of Huntingon’s. Because I had tested positive for the mutation, often “my fright of hard disk kept me from sitting downwardly amongst her in addition to attempting to converse,” I 1 time wrote.

In the “Foreword” to The Interviews, Guthrie’s missy Nora recalls her ain hesitancy every bit a 15-year-old to accomplish out to her manful somebody raise in addition to how she ultimately learned to appreciate the human being who, despite HD, understood his daughter’s feelings, a human being who possessed “twinkling eyes in addition to a mischievous grin, releasing us all to alive our ain lives completely in addition to wonderfully, taking each twenty-four hr menses in addition to each province of affairs every bit it comes.” Her manful somebody raise “lived amongst this disease, but he never became Huntington’s disease.”

“As I plough these pages, I tin finally reckon a beauty that has taken me over l years to recognize,” Nora writes of Buehler’s photographs of the infirmary where she, her woman raise Marjorie, in addition to brothers Arlo in addition to Joady visited Guthrie on the weekends in addition to held picnics on the lawn, the children often playing inwards a large tree their manful somebody raise dubbed the “magicky tree.” “These images are simply ruins, the gross leftovers, the niggling pieces, chipped in addition to peeling fragments of a life felt in addition to lived therefore vividly in addition to boldly.”

Discrimination in addition to misdiagnosis

The Guthries’ story became my family’s story, too. I remembered how I had travelled from my dwelling theater inwards San Diego to see my woman raise inwards the nursing dwelling theater inwards suburban Cleveland presently before she died. She shared a room amongst a adult woman paralyzed from the cervix down. The attendants tried to feed my woman raise but didn’t give her much to a greater extent than than a few spoonfuls before quitting. Always patient, my manful somebody raise had done a improve undertaking of feeding her when she was silent at home. He would feed her 1 time a twenty-four hr menses at the nursing home, too. Still, she was losing energy, piece of cake slipping towards death.

As the books recount, Guthrie faced the form of discrimination silent faced yesteryear hard disk people today: police describe officers in addition to fellow member of the full general populace often believe that hard disk people are drunk. In 1956, Guthrie was picked upward yesteryear New Bailiwick of Jersey province troopers, who thought he was a vagrant. Only after a telephone telephone vociferation upward from a friend did the troopers encompass that he needed medical attention.

At first, the medical personnel at Greystone refused to believe Guthrie’s claims to have got written thousands of songs. Instead, they described him every bit “delusional” and diagnosed him every bit a paranoid schizophrenic. hard disk is ofttimes misdiagnosed, inwards constituent because many doctors have got niggling or no cognition of the disease.

“Paranoid schizophrenia was a really mutual misdiagnosis – as were others including Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s, all kinds of psychiatric illnesses in addition to people were precisely locked away,” says Dr. Michael Hayden, a world-renowned hard disk goodness in addition to leader inwards the quest for treatments, inwards an interview amongst Buehler.

It took years to regain the get of my mother’s difficulties. She, too, had received dissimilar diagnoses, in addition to some of her doctors seemed indifferent or unwilling to acquire her to the right specialist. At foremost she was set on Haldol, an anti-psychotic also used to seek to command chorea inwards HD. I chop-chop learned, however, that neurologists who understood hard disk avoided Haldol because of negative side effects, therefore nosotros got her off of it every bit chop-chop every bit possible.

A hard environment

The foremost 2 images inwards Buehler’s operate are Guthrie’s Greystone intake photographs, which Buehler found inwards the basement of the admissions building, shown on the adjacent page inwards a recent shot yesteryear the author. Later nosotros come upward across Guthrie’s bed inwards Ward eighteen of the hospital building.

Images of Greystone Park State Hospital in addition to a missive of the alphabet written in that location yesteryear Woody Guthrie (photos from www.woodyguthrie.org)

“I think 1 fourth dimension walking through the entire ward amongst beds lined on both sides to acquire to my father’s bed at the really end,” Nora recalls inwards the accompanying text. “The walk seemed to have got forever. All precisely about us were foreign people yelling, talking to themselves, uninhibited or somber.”

I’ve learned that most hard disk patients are mixed inwards amongst individuals amongst other weather inwards facilities where personnel have got little, if any, cognition of HD. hard disk theater unit of measurement members must often educate wellness personnel almost the disease. Perhaps my woman raise would have got lived longer had in that location been a nursing dwelling theater amongst appropriate enrichment activities for her condition.

Guthrie lived most of the fourth dimension inwards Ward 40, which, amongst his typical mirth, he nicknamed “Wardy Forty,” as inwards the 1956 missive of the alphabet that appears inwards the book. Although hard disk yesteryear this fourth dimension had robbed Guthrie of his powerfulness to play guitar, he continued to write frequently, although ever less legibly.

My woman raise was ever inwards accuse of balancing the theater unit of measurement checkbook in addition to writing Christmas cards. For a spell after hard disk struck, she continued these activities. She used a ruler to brand perfectly direct lines on which to write addresses. She eventually lost the powerfulness to write.

A caregiver’s dedication

In a 1956 play titled “My Forsaken Bibel [sic],” written at Greystone, Guthrie responds to a friend’s inquiry almost how he inherited hard disk from his mother: “Hit my woman raise Nora Belle when she was almost 40. Made her precisely go into such trigger-happy fits in addition to such trigger-happy kinds of spasms that, well, she precisely wreckd [sic] in addition to precisely wracked every unmarried theater nosotros did alive in. My cardiographer over yonder inwards Brooklyn precisely told me my mother’s chorea sorta passled [sic] on to me here.” Nora Belle died inwards an Oklahoma mental infirmary inwards 1929.

My woman raise loved to sew. I think the Halloween costumes in addition to other wearable she made for me. One twenty-four hr menses she precisely stopped. She left scores of patterns unused. Like Guthrie, I dearest writing. I have got already passed my mother’s historic menses of onset. How much longer before hard disk erodes my powerfulness to limited myself? Will I demand to go into a nursing home? Will a handling live on found?

Marjorie loved in addition to cared for Guthrie despite the fact that they had separated almost a decade before because of strains over the disease. They eventually divorced. Near the halt of Wardy Forty, Buehler places photographs of the span at her Queens home, where she would have got her married adult man for visits.

“She stripped him of his clothes in addition to scrubbed him inwards the bath, sprinkling him amongst talcum pulverization in addition to singing, 'Doesn’t he olfactory holding sweetness now!'” Nora recalls inwards the accompanying text. “She would launder in addition to Fe his clothes, run upward up the tears, in addition to clothing him similar a woman raise dressing her kid for a foremost twenty-four hr menses of school.”

Once my father, daughter, in addition to I went amongst my woman raise to a park. My woman raise needed to usage the residual room. We had to elevator her from her wheelchair in addition to maneuver her clumsy in addition to unresponsive torso into the stall. It was similar moving dead weight. She nearly fell. When she was finished, nosotros had to repeat the procedure inwards reverse. Later, inwards her finally months of life inwards the nursing home, my manful somebody raise visited her every day. Dejected yesteryear her death, his ain dementia worsened dramatically. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 yr after she died, he started taking a large, beautiful, framed painting of her wherever he went, including restaurants. In 2009 he, too, died inwards a nursing home

Time to halt ‘throwing away’ people

The finally 2 images of Buehler’s volume are of Guthrie’s Greystone discharge photos from Apr 1961, which contrast amongst the 1956 frontal intake photo. Initially, Guthrie looks into the camera. His aspect is sad, but he appears relatively healthy. Upon discharge, however, he casts his eyes downward, typical of the difficulty HD-affected individuals have got amongst visual focus. He appears to have got lost much weight.

Arlo was xix when his manful somebody raise died. That same year, he released the vocal “Alice’s Restaurant,” a protestation of the Vietnam War draft. In 1969 he starred inwards the Hollywood painting based on the vocal in addition to performed at the Woodstock Festival. Arlo himself never tested for hard disk in addition to has non shown symptoms.

In Wardy Forty, Arlo has a potent message almost Greystone in addition to its residents: “These places were built therefore that they wouldn’t live on a burden on society. You could throw away your strange child, set him inwards 1 of these towns, almost similar sending people to Commonwealth of Australia from England years ago. Penal colonies. And therefore it’s no wonder why they ended upward inwards this sort of notoriously bad scene. They were gear upward from the really offset to live on away from the world, in addition to non live on constituent of it. Greystone is a existent monument to that.”

The thought behind Greystone silent largely governs our outlook on attention for the neurologically disabled.

People across the province are acting to right the situation. Maria Shriver in addition to erstwhile Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor – both lost loved ones to Alzheimer’s – have got warned the populace of the Alzheimer’s “tsunami” almost to hitting America.

In Vermont, HD activists successfully advocated for province laws preventing inappropriate transfers of nursing facility residents in addition to requiring populace assistance for home-based in addition to community-based care. At the national level, HDSA is pressuring Congress in addition to the Social Security Administration to update long-outdated in addition to inaccurate disability criteria for HD in addition to to waive the two-year waiting menses for patients to have Medicare benefits.

Responding to press reports of corruption in addition to abuses in addition to requests from advocates, California province legislators inwards Jan announced twelve bills aimed at addressing the inadequate attention inwards the state’s assisted living facilities in addition to nursing homes.

Indeed, the fourth dimension has come upward to develop a to a greater extent than compassionate monastic tell yesteryear valuing both the somebody cared for in addition to the caregiver.

Share this post