To Take, Or Non To Take, Unproven Supplements Inwards The Struggle Against Huntington’S Disease

Should people facing Huntington’s illness accept creatine together with other supplements to salve or forestall symptoms?

I do.

I saw hard disk inexorably destroy my mother’s powerfulness to walk, talk, together with tending for herself. She died viii years agone this month. I tested positive for hard disk inwards 1999 together with since thus receive got worried daily almost when it volition strike.

There is no handling to tedious HD’s destruction of the brain. So I’ve been opened upward to taking supplements that mightiness help.

In early on 1996, simply before long after learning of my mother’s diagnosis, I started taking coenzyme Q-10 (Co-Q), a vitamin-like amount flora throughout our bodies together with seen past times researchers equally a possible agency to assist remedy the unloose energy deficits suffered inwards HD.

In 2004, when Dr. LaVonne Goodman introduced a “treatment now” regimen together with clinical lawsuit of rubber supplements that had shown promising results inwards creature testing, I jumped at the run a jeopardy to participate. I was the exclusively presymptomatic private inwards the small, three-year study, run nether the auspices of Dr. Goodman’s Huntington’s Disease Drug Works (HDDW).

Starting inwards 2005, I introduced the supplements into my diet inwards steps. I worked upward to a daily routine inwards which I took 75 grams of trehalose, a saccharide that seems to help the encephalon clear cellular debris; 600 mg of medical-grade Co-Q; 2 g of omega-3 oil; 2 g of blueberry extract; together with x g of medical-grade creatine. The lawsuit paid for together with delivered the supplements.

The lawsuit did non demo meaning improvement for whatever of the symptomatic participants. “The exclusively affair that appeared to endure helpful was trehalose,” Dr. Goodman said inwards a Feb ix telephone interview. Today, almost a decade later, the supplements remain medically unproven to behavior upon HD.

Nevertheless, scientists even thus mean value that trehalose, Co-Q, together with creatine mightiness even thus render assist inwards treating HD. Since the destination of the HDDW, I receive got continued to accept all of the supplements, spending almost $2,000 per year. In fact, several years ago, relying on medical advice, I roughly doubled my daily intake of creatine to almost 20 g.

I acquire semi-annual blood tests to monitor potential kidney damage, which creatine tin cause. I also potable enough of H2O throughout the twenty-four hr menstruum to forestall dehydration, which tin occur at doses higher than 10 g. Creatine also tin displace weight gain.

Am I wasting coin together with endangering my health?

I don’t mean value so. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 few years ago, ane of the doctors at the local Huntington’s illness hospital told me to remain on the supplements, observing that the combination of substances mightiness endure helping to delay my hard disk onset. I inherited the same flat of mutation equally my mother, but, at 54, receive got passed the historic menstruum of her onset.

The yin-yang of supplements

Whether others inwards the hard disk community should accept creatine together with other supplements is an private alternative ideally made inwards consultation amongst a doctor.

During our interview, the Seattle-based Dr. Goodman reviewed the pros together with cons of taking creatine.

She cautioned against taking high doses of the substance, because to a greater extent than serious side effects occur at higher dosage, and urged people to consult a physician earlier starting whatever supplement.

She stressed that people ask to empathize the “yin-yang” involved inwards the determination to accept supplements.

“Yes, y'all desire to accept tending of yourself,” Dr. Goodman said. If they attain aught else, supplements tin at to the lowest degree furnish a “very important” placebo outcome together with the prospect of hope, she said.

Dr. LaVonne Goodman (photo past times Gene Veritas)

The placebo outcome is a “real” phenomenon, she observed. “If y'all could bottle it, it would endure great.”

However, taking supplements also reminds asymptomatic factor carriers of their risk, she added.

More importantly, people’s purpose of supplements could also obstruct the path to other, potentially far to a greater extent than promising treatments, she said.

The benefits of supplements “need to endure counterbalanced amongst the ask to exam promising novel drugs, or nosotros volition never receive got improve treatments for Huntington’s,” she explained.

Interfering amongst clinical trials?

“There are thus many competing interests here,” Dr. Goodman continued. “We all desire to believe that (creatine) is helpful, because it’s available, together with nosotros tin accept it, thus why non attain it, nosotros say. This is what I said amongst HDDW trials. Well, yes, but it needs to endure measured. Otherwise, we’re going to know aught to a greater extent than than nosotros did.”

“It is of import for people to know that if they accept these things, they can’t endure inwards clinical trials at the same time. We deplete our clinical lawsuit player base, which is going to impede progress for finding improve treatments. There’s the yin-yang. And people ask to remove heed both.”

However, Dr. Goodman noted that individuals could attain both: to acquire eligible for a clinical trial, individuals could clear the supplements out of their organisation thus that they don’t interfere amongst the measuring of the tested drug’s effects, thus resume the supplements after completing the trial.

I would halt taking my supplements inwards gild to qualify for a trial, although until the most recent creatine lawsuit (see below), practically every lawsuit has targeted exclusively symptomatic individuals.

Dr. Goodman underscored the ask to process creatine together with all other supplements equally “medicines.” Supplements should encounter USP (U.S. Pharmacopeial Convention) standards, she added. The HDDW website contains data on supplement safety. Further data on supplements is available at Huntington’s Disease Lighthouse Families.

(I purchase my creatine from my local GNC outlet but computer program to search for a improve marker of the product.)

All drugs, including FDA-approved ones, attain side effects together with tin behavior upon individuals differently, Dr. Goodman noted.

Regarding creatine, she concluded: “If it’s non watched closely, it may displace to a greater extent than harm than good.”

A historic trial

People inwards the hard disk community became excited almost creatine equally a potential handling after Harvard University’s online intelligence service on Feb seven published an article titled I wrote inwards 2011. “It’s actually the Holy Grail non exclusively for HD, but also for other neurological diseases such equally Alzheimer’s inwards which encephalon harm occurs many years earlier symptoms appear. Ideally, researchers desire to pattern medications that volition completely forestall these diseases.”

The Neurology editorial used the term “Holy Grail,” too, inwards noting how the PRESCREST report “investigates a potentially neuroprotective agent designed to delay illness onset.”

The give-and-take “potentially” is key.

As Dr. Hersch explained, the PRECREST findings almost slower shrinkage “suggest” that creatine provides a benefit, but they don’t permit researchers to state anything almost delayed onslaught of symptoms inwards presymptomatic individuals or a longer lifespan for patients.

It remains for the CREST-E Phase III lawsuit to attain similar encephalon scan results – and an actual outcome on symptoms.

“If CREST-E shows efficacy inwards slowing downwardly the illness inwards people who are symptomatic, I would mean value that most people would mean value that y'all may endure slowing downwardly the illness inwards people who aren’t symptomatic yet equally well,” he said.

Until treatments acquire available, presymptomatic factor carriers similar me volition hap to facial expression upward the extremely hard determination almost whether to accept supplements.

I’m grasping at creatine together with other supplements inwards the hopes of delaying onslaught until researchers succeed. 

Share this post